Commentary for Kiddushin 92:2

איתמר המקדש אחותו רב אמר מעות חוזרים ושמואל אמר מעות מתנה רב אמר מעות חוזרים אדם יודע שאין קידושין תופסין באחותו וגמר ונתן לשום פקדון ולימא לה לשום פקדון סבר לא מקבלה

Rab said: The money is returnable: one knows that kiddushin with a sister is invalid, hence he resolved and gave it as a deposit. Then let him tell her that it is a deposit? - He thought that she would not accept it. But Samuel holds, the money is a gift; one knows that kiddushin with a sister is invalid, and therefore he resolved and gave it as a gift.

Explore commentary for Kiddushin 92:2. In-depth commentary and analysis from classical Jewish sources.