Commentary for Menachot 5:12

לרבנן ה"נ לר"ש כיון דאמר ר"ש אף ידי נדרו יצא אלמא קביעותא דמנא ולא כלום הוא ולא שנא אמר זו ולא שנא אמר עלי

According to the view of the Rabbis this would indeed be [a difficulty]; but we are arguing according to the view of R'Simeon, and R'Simeon holds that [in the first case] he has even discharged the obligation of his vow.

Explore commentary for Menachot 5:12. In-depth commentary and analysis from classical Jewish sources.