Commentary for Menachot 5:2
חטאת העוף שהזה דמה למטה לשם עולת העוף תרצה דמעשיה מוכיחין עליה דחטאת עוף היא דאי עולת העוף היא למעלה הוה עביד לה ומיצוי הוה עביד ליה
Again, if he sprinkled the blood of the sin-offering of a bird below [the red line] under the name of a burnt-offering of a bird, it should discharge [the owner], since the treatment thereof indicates plainly that it is a sin-offering of a bird, for if it were a burnt-offering of a bird he would have performed [the sprinkling] above [the red line], and would also have drained out the blood? - This is so.<span class="x" onmousemove="('comment',' That according to R. Simeon in such a case the owner counts the offering as the fulfilment of his obligation.');"><sup>1</sup></span>
Explore commentary for Menachot 5:2. In-depth commentary and analysis from classical Jewish sources.