Commentary for Pesachim 156:2

אלא רואה אני דברי ר"א בדיעבד ודברי ר' יהושע לכתחלה דיעבד אפילו רבי יהושע נמי מודה הוא דקתני מודה רבי יהושע שאם זרק הורצה

One refers to uncleanness; the other to [the case where it] is lost or burnt. [Thus:] when does he teach, R'Joshua agrees that if he sprinkled [the blood] it is made acceptable, where [the flesh] was defiled, but not if it was lost or burnt; [and] when does R'Jose say, I agree with the words of R'Eliezer if it was done, where [the flesh] was lost or burnt.

Explore commentary for Pesachim 156:2. In-depth commentary and analysis from classical Jewish sources.