Commentary for Pesachim 197:4
א"ר אשי מתניתין נמי דייקא דקתני וכן חמש חבורות של חמשה חמשה של חמשה אין אבל של חמשה וארבעה לא לאו משום דלא פייש חד מבני חבורה גביה שמע מינה:
this is R'Judah's view. R'Jose said: Providing that they do not leave the Paschal sacrifice as it is!<span class="x" onmousemove="('comment',' Without owners. Now R. Judah must mean that one of the persons who originally registered for it, when the animal was first set aside for a Passover-offering, must remain registered for it, while in R. Jose's opinion it is sufficient that someone remains, even if he is not of those who originally registered for it. For if R. Judah's view Is not as stated, it does not differ in any way from R. Jose's. But in the Mishnah, when A, the only original owner of one of the sacrifices, declares, 'If this animal is not mine, I withdraw from the other and register for this', the other is left without anyone who first registered for it, since A is the only original owner.');"><sup>5</sup></span>
Explore commentary for Pesachim 197:4. In-depth commentary and analysis from classical Jewish sources.