Commentary for Rosh Hashanah 47:7

ת"ר ראינוהו ושוב לא ראינוהו אין מעידין עליו כל הכי חזו לה ואזלי

Since you disallow them [when they see] the whole, can there be any question [when they see] only half? - In fact the statement should run as follows: '[If they say they saw] half of it in water and half in the sky, half of it through the clouds and h in the sky, half of it in a mirror and half in the sky, they are not allowed to testify.' Our Rabbis taught: [If they say], We saw it [once], but did not see it again, they are not allowed to testif concerning it.

Explore commentary for Rosh Hashanah 47:7. In-depth commentary and analysis from classical Jewish sources.