Commentary for Temurah 45:5
במתכפר באבודה דרבי סבר
the second [sin-offering] dies.<span class="x" onmousemove="('comment',' Even if it was the sin-offering which was never lost, since he thus showed deliberately that he was not concerned with it. For the Rabbis dispute only where the owner comes to consult the Beth din, thus showing that he is seeking a remedy, e.g., where he set aside a sin-offering and it was lost and then the first was found and he comes before us to consult as to what he should do. According to Rabbi we say to him, 'Obtain atonement through the sin-offering which was never lost', and the lost sin-offering is condemned to die, whereas according to the Rabbis we say to him, 'Obtain atonement through the lost sin-offering', and the other one is condemned to pasture.');"><sup>5</sup></span>
Explore commentary for Temurah 45:5. In-depth commentary and analysis from classical Jewish sources.