Jewish%20thought for Kiddushin 101:5

הרי תודה דליתא בטעות וליתא נמי בזה אחר זה ואיתמר תודה שנשחטה על שמונים חלות חזקיה אמר קדשי לה ארבעים מתוך שמונים ור' יוחנן אמר לא קדשי לה ארבעים מתוך שמונים

But what of the thanksgiving-offering which can neither be in error nor consecutively,<span class="x" onmousemove="('comment',' The thanksgiving-offering was accompanied by forty loaves, which were likewise sanctified (v. Lev, VII, 12ff: and Men. 76a) . Now, if the animal is sacrificed to sanctify certain loaves, which, however, are not really those intended, they are not sanctified. Again, if after forty loaves are sanctified another forty are declared holy, the declaration is invalid.');">⁸</span> yet it was stated: If the thanksgiving-offering is slaughtered over eighty loaves, - Hezekiah said: Forty out of the eighty are sanctified; R'Johanan said: Not even forty out of the eighty are sanctified!<span class="x" onmousemove="('comment',' The controversy is assumed to centre on Rabbah's dictum. Hezekiah, R. Johanan's teacher, thus contradicts Rabbah.');">⁹</span>

Explore jewish%20thought for Kiddushin 101:5. In-depth commentary and analysis from classical Jewish sources.