Quoting%20commentary for Moed Katan 31:19

אמר אמימר הלכתא הני בי תלתא דשמיתו אתו בי תלתא אחריני ושרו ליה א"ל רב אשי לאמימר והא תניא רשב"ג אומר אחד מן התלמידים שנידה ומת חלקו אינו מופר מאי לאו אינו מופר כלל לא עד דאתו בי תלתא אחריני ושרו ליה

binds and a toot releases!"' [Said Abaye] to him, Yea, but this obtains only in the case of disregarding a monetary decision, but in a case of contumacy [it holds] until it has rested on him for thirty days! Anyhow, that shows that Abaye was of opinion that if three people had pronounced the shammetha on a man three others cannot come and release him!<span class="x" onmousemove="('comment',' [Rashi! Since he himself was anxious to perform the release. In var. lec. supra n. 6 the question is clear.]');">³⁶</span> For the question was raised: If three people had pronounced the shammetha on a man, can three others come and remit it for him? - Come and hear: 'One who has been "separated" [under a ban] by the master is [deemed as] "separated" from the disciple;<span class="x" onmousemove="('comment',' I.e., the ban is effective also as far as the disciple is concerned; and similarly in all the other cases that follow.');">³⁷</span> but one who has been "separated" by the disciple is not [considered as] "separated" from the master.

Explore quoting%20commentary for Moed Katan 31:19. In-depth commentary and analysis from classical Jewish sources.