Related%20passage for Shabbat 182:5

אלא אסקופה כרמלית והא קמ"ל טעמא דנח בכרמלית הא לא נח בכרמלית מיחייב מתני' דלא כבן עזאי דתניא המוציא מחנות לפלטיא דרך סטיו חייב ובן עזאי פוטר:

<b><i>GEMARA</i></b>. What is this threshold? Shall we say, a threshold that is public ground? [How state then] 'HE IS NOT CULPABLE'! Surely he has carried out from private into public ground? Again, if it is a threshold that is private ground, [how state then] WHETHER HE [HIMSELF] SUBSEQUENTLY CARRIES IT OUT [INTO THE STREET] OR ANOTHER DOES SO, HE IS NOT CULPABLE'? Surely he carries out from private into public ground? Rather the threshold is a <i>karmelith</i>,<span class="x" onmousemove="('comment',' Supra 6a. ');">⁸</span> and he [the Tanna] informs us this: The reason [that he is not culpable] is because it rested in the <i>karmelith</i>; but if it did not rest in the <i>karmelith</i> he would be liable,<span class="x" onmousemove="('comment',' Though it was carried out by way of a karmelith. ');">⁹</span>

Explore related%20passage for Shabbat 182:5. In-depth commentary and analysis from classical Jewish sources.