Related for Bava Metzia 217:15
ההוא שתלא דאמר להו אי מפסדינא מסלקנא אפסיד אמר רב יהודה מסתלק בלא שבחא רב כהנא אמר מסתלק ושקיל שבחא ומודה רב כהנא דאי אמר אי פסידנא מסתלקנא בלא שבחא מסתלק בלא שבחא רבא אמר אסמכתא היא ואסמכתא לא קניא
R. Papa leased a field for growing fodder. Now, some young trees sprouted up therein. When he [R. Papa] was about to quit, he said to them [the original owners]: Give me the improvement,<span class="x" onmousemove="('comment',' The value of the trees. ');"><sup>12</sup></span>
Tosefta Ketubot
If the son sold [property written to him by his father for after his death] and (sic! according to Ehrfurt manuscript and most Rishonim, see Lieberman's notes) his father died, if there is property [still] attached to the ground [i.e. that the buyer has not used in the meantime], they evaluate for him [i.e. the property returns to the inheritors, but the buyer gets a certain amount of money as if he were a tenant, see end of this halakhah, also Lieberman and Tosefta Ketubot 8:4 above]. One who receives a field from his fellow [and then the original owner wants it back] which is an irrigated field or orchard [two types of field that are a lot of work to look after], if there is property attached to the ground, they evaluate for him [as a tenant]. One who receives a field from his fellow and the 7th year arrives, if there is property attached to the ground, they evaluate for him. (The following is not in the printed edition but supplied by Ehrfrut manuscript:) One who receives a field from his fellow and the time arrives when he has to leave, if there are [property] attached to the ground, they evaluate for him. And for all of these, they evaluate them as if he were a tenant.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy