Related for Rosh Hashanah 54:15
תניא נמי הכי התוקע לתוך הבור או לתוך הדות יצא והתנן לא יצא אלא לאו שמע מינה כדרב הונא ש"מ
Some attach R'Johanan's remark to the latter clause: 'If with another material it is not valid': Said R'Johanan: This is the case only if the greater part of the original wa removed. From this we infer that if the stoppage is made with the same material, even though the greater part of the original is gone it is valid.<span class="x" onmousemove="('comment',' The quotation from the Baraitha is here resumed.');"><sup>14</sup></span>
Tosefta Rosh Hashanah (Lieberman)
If a horn was long and he shortened it, then it is fit. If he has scraped it inside or outside, it is good. Ha [a]he disguises it inside, it is useless ; [if he] has it [covered up] on the outside, then it is fit for purpose. Did [a]he disguise the mouthpiece or did he extended, even if [it happened] with [material] of the same kind, it is invalid. If it was punctured, and if [a]er [then] stopped it, even if [it was done] with [material] of the same kind, it is unsuitable if it prevents blowing; but if not, it is fit. If he has put two horns together and blown them, then when he has heard the sound of the inner one, he has done his duty; if he has heard the sound of the outside, then he has not fulfilled his duty. The size of the horn: that [d]er [bloa-ser] take it with his hand and blow kana
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
Tosefta Rosh Hashanah (Lieberman)
If a horn was long and he shortened it, then it is fit. If he has scraped it inside or outside, it is good. Ha [a]he disguises it inside, it is useless ; [if he] has it [covered up] on the outside, then it is fit for purpose. Did [a]he disguise the mouthpiece or did he extended, even if [it happened] with [material] of the same kind, it is invalid. If it was punctured, and if [a]er [then] stopped it, even if [it was done] with [material] of the same kind, it is unsuitable if it prevents blowing; but if not, it is fit. If he has put two horns together and blown them, then when he has heard the sound of the inner one, he has done his duty; if he has heard the sound of the outside, then he has not fulfilled his duty. The size of the horn: that [d]er [bloa-ser] take it with his hand and blow kana
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy