Commentary for Chullin 243:14
כי קאמר ר"ע ה"מ פלטתו סכין אבל פלטתו חיה לא בטיל קמ"ל טעמא דר"ע מפני שהעור מבטלן ל"ש פלט חיה ול"ש פלט סכין
- You must therefore say that even where the knife cut it away it is not rendered negligible according to R'Ishmael; and R'Huna<span class="x" onmousemove="('comment',' I.e., the second dictum of R. Huna ('If there were two pieces of flesh' etc.) accords with R. Akiba; the first dictum of R. Huna which interprets the view of R Judah in our Mishnah ('Provided he collected it together') accords with R. Ishmael.');"><sup>8</sup></span>
Explore commentary for Chullin 243:14. In-depth commentary and analysis from classical Jewish sources.