Commentary for Ketubot 76:5

בשלמא ר"ע דמתני' לא אתיא ג"ש ומפקא ליה לקרא מפשטיה לגמרי אלא לר"ע דברייתא אתיא גזירה שוה ומפקא מפשטיה לגמרי

It goes well for R. Akiva in our Mishnah since the gezerah shavah does not altogether remove the verse from its simple meaning. But according to R. Akiva in the baraita, the gezerah shavah removes the verse completely from its simple meaning!

Explore commentary for Ketubot 76:5. In-depth commentary and analysis from classical Jewish sources.