Commentary for Kiddushin 32:13
לא אידי ואידי דנפקא לה בסימנין ולא קשיא הא דאיתיה לאב הא דליתיה לאב
And should you reply: He teaches that which is fixed, but not that which is not fixed - but what of 'signs', which are not fixed, and which he nevertheless teaches? And should you answer: Here too, it is as R'Safra - but there is the master's death! This refutation of Resh Lakish is indeed a refutation.
Daf Shevui to Kiddushin
There is another way to harmonize the baraitot—if she has a father, he receives the gift. If her father has died, and then she goes free by “signs,” then she receives the gift. But her father’s death does not cause her to go free.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy