Commentary for Makkot 36:11

קרייה אקרייה לא קשיא הא רבי שמעון הא רבנן הנחה אהנחה נמי לא קשיא הא רבי יהודה והא רבנן

Recitation on recitation is not a contradiction. This is [the opinion of] Rebbi Shimon [who says that recitation is essential] and this is [the opinion of] the Rabbis [who argue on Rebbi Shimon] Placement on placement is also not a contradiction. This is [the opinion of] Rebbi Yehuda [who says that placement is not essential] and this is the opinion of the Rabbis [who argue on Rebbi Yehudah.]

Explore commentary for Makkot 36:11. In-depth commentary and analysis from classical Jewish sources.