Related for Gittin 108:12
ודלמא דשמעניה דפגיל אי לאו דמהימן אע"ג דשמעניה נמי לא מהימן דדלמא לבתר הכי קאמר
A certain man said to another: The clean things which I helped you to prepare on such and such a day have become unclean. He applied to R. Ammi, who said to him: According to the strict letter of the law, you need not believe him. R. Assi observed to him: Rabbi, this is what you say, but R. Johanan has distinctly said in the name of R. Jose: What can I do, seeing that the Torah has declared him credible?<span class="x" onmousemove="('comment',' Even when he declares if after some time. ');"><sup>11</sup></span>
Tosefta Terumot
[Relatedly, if the friend] was bringing a sacrifice with him, and he said to [the friend], "[This sacrifice] has become piggul," [or] if he was preparing pure food with him, and he said, "It became impure," a Jew is not suspected on these things. But [if] he said to him, "The sacrifice that I brought with you became impure on the same day," by the the letter of the law, he is not to be believed. Rabbi Yehudah says, a Jew is [typically] not suspected on these things, but everything goes according to what kind of a man he is.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
Tosefta Terumot
[Relatedly, if the friend] was bringing a sacrifice with him, and he said to [the friend], "[This sacrifice] has become piggul," [or] if he was preparing pure food with him, and he said, "It became impure," a Jew is not suspected on these things. But [if] he said to him, "The sacrifice that I brought with you became impure on the same day," by the the letter of the law, he is not to be believed. Rabbi Yehudah says, a Jew is [typically] not suspected on these things, but everything goes according to what kind of a man he is.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy