Related for Menachot 45:10
תיבעי לר' יוחנן ותיבעי לריש לקיש תיבעי לר' יוחנן עד כאן לא קא אמר ר' יוחנן התם אלא בעצם דמינא דבשר הוא אבל האי דלאו דמינא דקומץ הוא לא
to the thing offered is like the offering itsel 'Resh Lakish says, He is not liable', because what is joined to the thing offered is not like the offering! - Th question can indeed be asked, both according to R'Johanan and according to Resh Lakish. It can be asked according to R'Johanan, for [it may be that] R'Johanan held that view only in regard to the bone, since it is of the same kind as the flesh, but not in regard to [the wood] for it is not of the same kind as the handful.
Shulchan Arukh, Yoreh De'ah
If it is was mixed with something of the same type and it was spilled, in a case where one can not deal with it to measure it, if it is known that it was majority permissible, [it is] permissible. And if it is not known that it was majority permissible, [it is] forbidden. Rema: And in the matter of "being of the same type" we follow the name, if it is the same then this is "of the same type," but we do not follow the taste if it is the same or not. But if was mixed with something that is not of the same type and it spilled in a case where one can not deal with it to measure it, even it is known that it was majority permissible, [it is] forbidden. And if it was mixed with "of its kind" and with "not of its kind" and it spilled in a case where one can not deal with it to measure it, and it is known that it was majority "of its kind", one views the "not of its kind" as though it were not [present], and the rest, "of its kind" is greater and negates it.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy