Related for Pesachim 78:9
בעי רמי בר חמא מהו שיצא אדם ידי חובתו במרור של מעשר שני בירושלים אליבא דר' עקיבא לא תיבעי לך השתא במצה דאורייתא נפיק במרור דרבנן מיבעי'
In reference to the stalk. An objection is raised: One can discharge [the obligation] with them and their stalks, both moist and dry: this is R'Meir's view. But the Sages maintain: One can discharge [the obligation] with moist [fresh] ones, but one cannot discharge [the obligation] with dry ones.
Tosefta Pesachim
Rabbi Yehuda ben Beteira says, they fulfill [the obligation of eating bitter herbs] with lettuce (חזרת) and with mustard. Rabbi Yishmael bar Rabbi Yochanan ben Berokah says, one does not fulfull [the obligation] with anything that burns [the mouth]. Rabbi Yehuda says, anything that makes one pale [after eating it] fulfills [the obligation]. They may fulfill [the obligation] either with wet or dry [bitter herbs]. Rabbi Meir says, [the halacha should rather be formulated as] "they even fulfill [their obligation] with dry [bitter herbs]." Rabbi Tzadok says, [the halacha should rather be formulated as] "they even fulfill [their obligation] with pickled [bitter herbs]."
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy