Responsa for Makkot 6:9
הא איתמר עלה אמר רב ענן לדידי מפרשא ליה מיניה דשמואל על מנת שאין לך עלי אונאה אין לו עליו אונאה על מנת שאין בו אונאה הרי יש בו אונאה
No, R' Anan said, Shmuel explained it to me himself, on condition that you have no fraud against me, there is no fraud, [but if he says] there is no fraud [at all], there is fraud.
Teshuvot Maharam
Q. In the controversy between Rav and Samuel (B. M. 51a) regarding a person who concluded a sale on the condition that there be no claim of redress for overreaching, whose opinion prevails?
A. The opinion of Rav is accepted by all authorities. Notwithstanding the agreement to the contrary, a claim of redress for overreaching would be upheld.
SOURCES: P. 50.
A. The opinion of Rav is accepted by all authorities. Notwithstanding the agreement to the contrary, a claim of redress for overreaching would be upheld.
SOURCES: P. 50.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy