Responsa for Sukkah 72:5

א"ד אמר רב זה הדר דהא ר' חנינא מטביל בה ונפיק בה ולרבי חנינא קשיא מתניתין ל"ק כאן ביו"ט ראשון כאן ביו"ט שני:

There are those who say: Rav ruled that "goodly" since R. Hanina tasted a part [of an etrog] and fulfilled his obligation [with the remainder]. But is not our Mishnah a difficulty against R. Hanina? There is no contradiction since the former refers to the first day of the Festival, while the latter refers to the second day.

Explore responsa for Sukkah 72:5. In-depth commentary and analysis from classical Jewish sources.