Responsa על יומא 59:3
Shut min haShamayim
They responded: we do not make comparisons between commandments. 3cf. Bava Batra 130b:11, אין אומרין בטרפות זו דומה לזו. For there are simple commandments, such as Sukkah and Lulav, and the punishment for negating them is severe, because it is tantamount to a rejection. Negating part of a commandment is not the same as negating all of it, for 'the Torah was not given to heavenly angels'.4The Torah is not stricter than normal people can bear. Cf. Yoma 30a:2 etc. All this they responded to me in truth. It seems that the punishment is not as severe as for one who negates the commandment of sitting in a Sukkah. Nonetheless, we are still at fault. For we do not put on tefillin for fear lest we flatulate or fall asleep while wearing them. Yet it is better to negate part of a commandment than all of it.*A similar ambiguity is noted by Tosafot on Shabbat 49a:6 - without denying that Tefillin should ideally be worn all day long, they note that 'we are lax with tefillin, just as they were lax in Talmudic times too'.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
Shut min haShamayim
Regarding the obligation to recite the blessing on washing the hands every time one exits the toilet and wishes to study Torah or recite the afternoon or evening prayers. For just as in the morning one recites the blessing, so too every time that hand-washing is required, one should recite the blessing.*There are at least two questions here: whether each of the three daily prayers should be preceded by hand-washing, and whether study of Torah requires ritual hand-washing too. On the first issue, see Rosh on Berachot 9:23 who holds that the blessing on hand-washing should be recited before prayer, but not after going to the toilet otherwise. Rashba reports this issue as a dispute between the Raavad, who required the blessing each time after going to the toilet, and the Ramban, who only required it in the morning (see Teshuvot Hameyuchasot LaRamban 173). See also Tosafot Yeshanim on Yoma 30a:1, where Rabbeinu Tam and his father Rabbeinu Meir hold that handwashing is sometimes required after the toilet, but not a blessing, while others did require it. On the issue of Torah study, see Sefer Mitzvot Katan 181:2, where 'our rabbis' are said to have washed their hands before studying Torah.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy