Chasidut for Chagigah 29:6
אפקוהו למיטטרון ומחיוהו שיתין פולסי דנורא א"ל מ"ט כי חזיתיה לא קמת מקמיה איתיהיבא ליה רשותא למימחק זכוותא דאחר יצתה בת קול ואמרה (ירמיהו ג, יד) שובו בנים שובבים חוץ מאחר
They took Mitatron out, and gave him sixty lashes of fire. They said to him, "What is your reason, that when you saw him, you did not stand before him?" He had permission to erase the merits of Acher. A heavenly voice went out and said, "'Return, rebellious children (Jeremiah 3:14)-' except for Acher."
Kedushat Levi
“And Avraham had aged, advanced in years;" the Talmud Baba batra 16 understands the word בכל as meaning that Avraham had a “daughter” by the name of בכל. Commenting further on this, the Talmud in Chagigah 15 states that a heavenly voice i.e. בת קול [instead of בת כל Ed.] was heard at Mount Sinai calling the Israelites to penance with the exception of Acher, (Elisha ben Avuya) turned apostate.
[The text in my edition of the Talmud does not mention the location where this heavenly voice was heard, and it would not make sense that it was Mount Sinai, as the occasion appears to have been at least 50 years after destruction of the second Temple. Ed.]
We need to examine the nature of this “voice” somewhat more closely. Since, according to the Talmud, this בת קול appears to have been a visual manifestation rather than something heard with one’s ears, the statement is enigmatic. Apparently, the Talmud refers to a message that a person hears or is supposed to hear daily as if it were as real as a vision. The true call to do teshuvah had originated at Sinai when the people had heard G’d address them directly during the first and second Commandment, until they were so overwhelmed that they feared to die and begged Moses to be their interpreter of G’d’s words. Mount Sinai had been referred to as Mount Chorev in Exodus 3,1 when Moses had his first vision of G’d at the burning bush. On that occasion he had “heard” the voice of G’d. The term בת קול has become the name for a derivative of that first communication to His people through Moses their leader and prophet ever since. At the revelation at Mount Sinai several months later, it had become so real that the people were described as “seeing” the voice rather than as merely “hearing it. (Exodus 20,15) We have explained that the term בן or בת describes the receiving of G’d’s largesse, when it has originated from G’d directly through the merits of the patriarch Avraham. Just as G’d had to “reduce Himself” in terms of His pure spirituality, man has to reduce his “physicality,” i.e. his dependence on physical comforts provided by our world somewhat, in order to qualify for receiving these communications from G’d. Each human being desirous of coming closer to G’d by this means has to do so in accordance with the spiritual level he is capable of. The word בת in the language of the Mishnah, is the preface used when describing the measure of certain liquids or dry matter that a container can hold. Its use in that sense originates in Ezekiel 45,10. [It may be correct to understand the term בת קול which is usually associated with post Biblical times, when there was no more direct communication with G’d through prophets or even through the urim vetumim on the High Priest’s breast plate, as a prophetic communication from G’d, but at arm’s length. Ed.]
[The text in my edition of the Talmud does not mention the location where this heavenly voice was heard, and it would not make sense that it was Mount Sinai, as the occasion appears to have been at least 50 years after destruction of the second Temple. Ed.]
We need to examine the nature of this “voice” somewhat more closely. Since, according to the Talmud, this בת קול appears to have been a visual manifestation rather than something heard with one’s ears, the statement is enigmatic. Apparently, the Talmud refers to a message that a person hears or is supposed to hear daily as if it were as real as a vision. The true call to do teshuvah had originated at Sinai when the people had heard G’d address them directly during the first and second Commandment, until they were so overwhelmed that they feared to die and begged Moses to be their interpreter of G’d’s words. Mount Sinai had been referred to as Mount Chorev in Exodus 3,1 when Moses had his first vision of G’d at the burning bush. On that occasion he had “heard” the voice of G’d. The term בת קול has become the name for a derivative of that first communication to His people through Moses their leader and prophet ever since. At the revelation at Mount Sinai several months later, it had become so real that the people were described as “seeing” the voice rather than as merely “hearing it. (Exodus 20,15) We have explained that the term בן or בת describes the receiving of G’d’s largesse, when it has originated from G’d directly through the merits of the patriarch Avraham. Just as G’d had to “reduce Himself” in terms of His pure spirituality, man has to reduce his “physicality,” i.e. his dependence on physical comforts provided by our world somewhat, in order to qualify for receiving these communications from G’d. Each human being desirous of coming closer to G’d by this means has to do so in accordance with the spiritual level he is capable of. The word בת in the language of the Mishnah, is the preface used when describing the measure of certain liquids or dry matter that a container can hold. Its use in that sense originates in Ezekiel 45,10. [It may be correct to understand the term בת קול which is usually associated with post Biblical times, when there was no more direct communication with G’d through prophets or even through the urim vetumim on the High Priest’s breast plate, as a prophetic communication from G’d, but at arm’s length. Ed.]
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
Kedushat Levi
Alternately, Moses refers to what our sages said when they spoke about a heavenly voice emanating from Mount Chorev which can be heard daily proclaiming that the Lord our G’d the Lord is One, imploring the Jewish people to return to G’d in penitence, and that the righteous are able to hear this voice.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy