Talmud Bavli
Talmud Bavli

Commentary for Ketubot 185:16

תניא זו משנת רבי נתן רבי אומר אין אני רואה דבריו של רבי נתן באלו אלא חולקות בשוה:

It was taught: This is the teaching of R. Natan. Rabbi said, “I do not agree with R. Natan’s views in these [cases], rather they each take equal shares.”

Tosafot on Ketubot

"I do not agree with Rabbi Natan, rather, they divide the estate equally." Rabbeinu Hananel ruled according to Rabbi Yehuda Hanasi understood the division as follows:  it is unimaginable that when there are only 300 dinar available, that the one claiming a hundred receives 100, the one claiming two hundred receives 100, and the one claiming three hundred receives 100. The principle of justice is lacking here! Rather, what Rabbi Yehuda Hanasi must mean is that each of the dinars that they are owed have equal power. Therefore, the estate of the deceased is divided into six. The one owed one hundred takes one part, the one owed two hundred takes two parts, and the one owed three hundred takes three parts. Each of them claims according to the money owed to her until they come as close as possible to being payed. This is justice, and this is what he must have meant. 
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
Previous VerseFull ChapterNext Verse