Musar for Makkot 33:18
אם לאוכלן חוץ לחומה ק"ו ממעשר אם לפני זריקה קל וחומר מתודה ושלמים אם לאחר זריקה ק"ו מבכור אם חוץ לקלעים קל וחומר מחטאת ואשם הא לא בא הכתוב
If to [make one liable for eating them] outside the wall [of Jerusalem], [then we could have just learned it out from] a kal v'chomer from maiser; if to [make one liable for eating them] before the z'rika, [then we could have just learned it out from] a kal v'chomer from Todah and Sh'lamim; if to [make one liable for eating them] after the z'rika, [then we could have just learned it out from] a kal v'chomer from Bechor; if to [make one liable for eating them] outside the [Temple] curtain, [then we could have just learned it out from] a kal v'chomer from Chatos and Asham rather the Torah comes
Shenei Luchot HaBerit
Commandment 448 prohibits the eating of קדשים קלים, i.e. offerings some parts of which may be consumed by the owner, before completion of the sprinkling of the blood on the altar. This is also derived from 12,17. The word ונדבותיך is understood as basically superfluous and therefore used to refer to premature consumption of freewill offerings such as תודה and שלמים.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy