Related for Ketubot 196:2
והתניא רבי יוסי אומר הכל לבעל המעות אמר רמי בר חמא לא קשיא כאן בדבר שיש לו קצבה כאן בדבר שאין לו קצבה
but R. Yose says, “They divide the profit.” But, surely, it was taught that R. Yose says, “All [profit belongs] to the owner of the money!” Rami b. Hama replied: This is no difficulty: the former refers to an object that has a fixed value while the latter refers to one that has no fixed value.
Tosefta Demai
[If] five said to one, "Go and bring us ten loaves of bread" [or] "[Go and bring us] ten bunches of vegetables," [and] he brings each one to his face (i.e., he brings that person what was purchased with that person's money), [then the] chaverim that are among them (i.e., among the purchasers) do not need to tithe except for their own portions. [But if] he brings them mixed together [so that he cannot tell which produce was purchased with which money], [then] the chaverim that are among them need to tithe on everything. If they gave him one in addition (i.e., the seller delivered one more item than was ordered, e.g., a baker's dozen), Rabbi Yehudah says, "It belongs to the messenger," and Rabbi Yosei says, "It is in the middle," (i.e., they all divide it, see Y. Dem. VI.8.6 ["רִבִּי יוֹסֵי אוֹמֵר שֶׁל שְׁנֵיהֶן"]).
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy